When hiring a traumatic brain injury lawyer in New York, should you ask the lawyer about his results in prior TBI cases he has handled?

Sponsored Answer
Andrew W. Siegel - Personal Injury - General - Super Lawyers

Answered by: Andrew W. Siegel

Located in New York, NYSiegel & Coonerty, LLP

New York, NY
Phone: 212-532-0532
Fax: 212-532-1871

View Profile

Yes. This is one of the most important questions you can ask. These are some of the case results for attorney Andy Siegel in traumatic brain injury cases:

Park -v- Rizzuti: $43,000,000.00 Jury Verdict

This result was the third largest verdict reported in the United States court system in 2007 for an individual plaintiff in a medical malpractice matter.

The TBI victim in this case was a 61-year-old woman. The claim was a failure to diagnose an abnormality on a CT, which turned out to be an aneurysm. It went untreated and subsequently ruptured leaving the plaintiff with severe brain damage.

Mouta -v- Essex, et. al.: $11,965,800.00 Jury Verdict

This case was selected by the editors of VerdictSearch as a "Featured Verdict." This result was the 15th largest verdict reported in the New York State court system in 2013.

The TBI victim in this case was a 43-year-old construction worker. The basic claim was a violation of the labor laws of the state of New York by failing to provide safety equipment. When the roof collapsed Mr. Mouta fell two stories with the back of his head striking the concrete.

John "Doe" -v- State of New York: Pretrial Settlement $9,480,000.00

In this matter, a seven-year-old boy sustained severe brain damage from the failure to timely diagnose and properly treat impending cardiopulmonary arrest from underlying medical conditions.

Jane “Doe” -v- Defendant Hospital: Pretrial Settlement $9,900,000.00

In this matter, an anesthesiologist lost track of the presenting aspect of a surgical wire as he was running it up the back of the patient’s neck just beneath her skin and it found its way into the foramen magnum (hole in base of skull) and into her brain resulting in a brain stem perforation with permanent brain damage. 

Crespo -v- DASNY, et. al.: Jury Verdict $6,000,000.00

Defendant did not provide plaintiff, a construction worker, with proper safety equipment who then sustained multiple facial fractures, trigeminal neuralgia and mild traumatic brain injury after a scaffold collapse. 

Saling -v- TBTA et. al.: Pretrial Settlement $2,500,000.00

The plaintiff was riding his motorcycle when his tires entered into a manmade rut between the middle and right hand lanes of Manhattan bound traffic. When his front tire struck a transverse joint that intersected the rut, he was thrown over his handlebars sliding forward on the roadway surface until his head contacted the bridge sidewall. He sustained a traumatic brain injury consisting of an anterior inferior frontal lobe injury that altered his personality and compromised his ability to inhibit his anger response.

MacKay -v- City of New York et. al.: Pretrial Settlement $1,000,000.00

The plaintiff was riding to work on his bicycle when his front tire went into a hole in the roadway throwing him over the handlebars. Plaintiff sustained an intracerebral hematoma requiring craniotomy. The defendant's position was that his current complaints were attributable to his continued consumption of alcohol for which he was hospitalized.

Disclaimer: The answer is intended to be for informational purposes only. It should not be relied on as legal advice, nor construed as a form of attorney-client relationship.

Other Answers By Andrew W. Siegel

Photo of Andrew W. Siegel

How to choose the best lawyer to handle a traumatic brain injury case in New York?

At, we would like to share a few simple “do’s and don’ts” to apply when selecting a lawyer to represent you …

Sponsored answer by Andrew W. Siegel

Other Answers About Brain Injury

Photo of Kyle Koester

When is my headache from a car crash in Georgia more than just a headache or concussion?

Everybody gets headaches, and it’s easy to dismiss them as an annoyance. Headaches, however, are one of the most reported symptoms that show up …

Sponsored answer by Kyle Koester

Photo of Lance D. Lourie

My child in Georgia was born with cerebral palsy. Could this have been prevented?

It’s no surprise that you have questions. A child you love more than anything or anyone in the world is faced with a lifetime of complications …

Sponsored answer by Lance D. Lourie

Photo of Michael S. Lamonsoff

I fell at work at a construction site in New York and hit my head. What steps should I take?

Falling at work can be a serious incident in itself, but falls that take place at a construction site tend to be much more dangerous and involve more …

Sponsored answer by Michael S. Lamonsoff

Call Me

To: Andrew W. Siegel

Super Lawyers: Potential Client Inquiry

Disclaimer »
Privacy Policy »
*Required fields
Page Generated: 1.5279319286346 sec