Are noncompete or nonsolicit agreements enforceable in New York?

Sponsored Answer
Henry L. Saurborn, Jr. - Employment Litigation - Super Lawyers

Answered by: Henry L. Saurborn, Jr.

Located in New York, NYKaiser Saurborn & Mair, P.C.

New York, NY
Phone: 212-338-9100
Fax: 646-607-9373

View Profile

New York's highest court has held that an employer can enforce noncompete agreements only where it can satisfy one of two elements: (1) Was the departing employee's job, skills and relationship with customers "unique and extraordinary" or (2) Has the employee taken from the former employer and used or attempted to use for personal benefit confidential information or trade secrets. Hence, it is more likely that an employee who holds an uncommon position and who has developed highly specialized knowledge about a firm's products, services, processes or methods, or enjoys a close and influential relationship with customers will be restricted in future employment than one who holds a position that is common, has little or no interaction with customers, or is not privy to sensitive information.

Likewise, the courts frown upon employees who steal nonpublic or competitively sensitive documents, data and information from their former employer and use that in an attempt to profit through later employment. And where there is sufficient evidence of such conduct, an employee should expect a court to impose restrictions on subsequent employment – including against new employers – even in the absence of a written noncompete agreement.

The considerations applicable to nonsolicit agreements are somewhat different and usually turn on when the former employee's relationship with the targeted person or firm was first established. Generally, if the departing employee was introduced to the customer or employee before first becoming employed at the firm seeking to enforce a nonsolicit provision, then he or she will be free to continue that relationship; otherwise, the former employer may be found to have a superior right to the relationship and can lawfully prevent the former employee from interfering for a reasonable period after the employment ends.

Because the question of the enforceability of noncompete and nonsolicit agreements or provisions is highly fact-specific, and requires the application of the many nuances that exist in this area of law, it is essential that an employee facing the potential enforcement of the same seek the advice of counsel experienced in this area of law.

Disclaimer: The answer is intended to be for informational purposes only. It should not be relied on as legal advice, nor construed as a form of attorney-client relationship.

Other Answers About Employment Law - Employee

Photo of Peter A. Romero

I Was Fired In New York Because I’m Pregnant. Can I Sue?

Pregnancy discrimination can also be a form of gender discrimination and may be demonstrated in several different …

Sponsored answer by Peter A. Romero

Photo of David A. Nacht

How do I negotiate a severance package in Michigan?

If you have been thinking, “I am about to get fired … now what?” You can calm the anxiety and …

Sponsored answer by David A. Nacht

Photo of Daniel A. Reisman

What should I do if an employer refuses to accommodate my disability in California?

Employees are entitled to reasonable accommodations for disabilities if the accommodation allows the employee to …

Sponsored answer by Daniel A. Reisman

Call Me

To: Henry L. Saurborn, Jr.

Super Lawyers: Potential Client Inquiry

Disclaimer »
Privacy Policy »
*Required fields
Page Generated: 0.90500283241272 sec